Should you kill Arnold in GTA 6

Should You Kill Arnold in GTA 6? What Happens If You Spare Him

Last checked: 19 November 2026. In the Chapter 1 mission “Hey Arnold!”, Jason chases Brian Heder’s broker Arnold to the docks and must decide: kill him or spare him. It feels like a big choice — but the honest answer is that it barely matters. Arnold leaves the game either way, the mission ends the same way, and there is no reward, payout or follow-up scene for either option. The only effect is on Jason’s Criminal Profile. Here is what happens each way, and why the choice is yours to make freely.

Should you kill Arnold in GTA 6? It does not matter to the story. In the Chapter 1 mission “Hey Arnold!”, the choice has no story consequences — Arnold leaves the game either way (spared, he swims off; killed, he dies) and the mission ends at Brian’s pool party either way, with Island Dreams unlocking next. The only effect is on Jason’s Criminal Profile: killing pushes it toward the violent, hardened end; sparing pushes it toward the restrained end.

The mission: Hey Arnold

Hey Arnold is a Chapter 1 mission — the eighth in VGC’s walkthrough order. Jason meets Brian at the bar, follows him to his truck, drives to the liquor store to collect Cal, and heads to the Radar Station to find Arnold, one of Brian’s contacts, who is annoyed about what went down with the Kingfishers during Gone Fishing. The meeting goes badly, and the chase begins: Arnold flees in his car, and the pursuit takes you over a Stunt Jump, flying over a section of broken bridge. At the end of the chase Arnold gets out of his car, and Jason chases him down on foot to the docks. That is where the choice happens.

If you kill Arnold

Arnold dies. Jason’s Criminal Profile shifts toward the violent, hardened end. There is no reward, no payout and no follow-up scene. One practical note from VGC: if you killed Arnold with a loud weapon like a gun, leave the area before the police arrive. It is also possible to kill Arnold and destroy his car during the chase, before he ever gets out — but VGC calls that significantly more difficult.

If you spare Arnold

Arnold swims off and leaves the game. Jason’s Criminal Profile shifts toward the restrained end. There is no reward, no payout and no follow-up scene — and, despite one outlet’s suggestion that sparing Arnold may lead to a reunion later, the consensus across VGC, Beebom, Sportskeeda and CryptoGames is that he is gone for good. The reunion claim comes from Game8 alone and is unconfirmed; do not spare Arnold expecting to see him again.

The verdict: it does not matter to the story

VGC’s verdict after shooting Arnold in its own playthrough: “outside of the criminal profile change, there were no real consequences to doing this.” The mission ends at Brian’s pool party either way, and Island Dreams unlocks next either way. The choice is a role-playing decision, not a branching one — pick the option that fits how you want to play Jason. One warning: there is no mission replay in GTA 6, so if you want to see the other branch you need an earlier manual save. See our save guide for how the 15 manual slots work.

A note on the Criminal Profile labels: the exact in-game label names vary across outlets — Beebom calls the killing direction “Violent”, Sportskeeda and Game8 call it “Hardened Criminal”, and our own research notes mention a “Psychopath” reputation. VGC, the strongest source, names no specific label. We describe the direction of the shift rather than a label we cannot verify.

Frequently asked questions

Should you kill Arnold in GTA 6?

It does not matter to the story. Arnold leaves the game either way, the mission ends at Brian’s pool party either way, and there is no reward for either choice. The only effect is on Jason’s Criminal Profile — killing pushes it toward the violent end, sparing toward the restrained end.

Does sparing Arnold in GTA 6 lead to a reunion?

No — not according to the consensus. VGC, Beebom, Sportskeeda and CryptoGames all say Arnold is gone for good either way. One outlet (Game8) suggests a reunion may be possible, but that is unconfirmed and contradicted by the other sources.

Sources

  • VGC — “GTA 6 Hey Arnold Walkthrough” (18 Nov 2026): the mission, the chase, the choice and its consequences, read directly.
  • Radio Times (19 Nov 2026, 11:10 UTC), Beebom, Sportskeeda, HowToVideoGame and CryptoGames: corroboration of the choice, the pool-party ending and the Criminal Profile effect.
  • Game8: the sole source for the “reunion” claim — unconfirmed, contradicted by the other outlets, and not stated as fact here.

Related guides

Similar Posts

2 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *